Walmart (WMT) and Target (TGT) both reported earnings last week… and the difference in the retailers’ results was staggering.

While Walmart is thriving and gaining market share across several key demographics, Target is struggling to keep up.

The two earnings reports paint a telling picture of how consumers are spending their money in today’s economic landscape.

Let’s look at what the latest results reveal… and how investors should navigate this economic landscape.

A tale of two retailers

Walmart continues to dominate, delivering robust earnings that exceeded expectations. The company is gaining market share not only in its core grocery segment—which accounts for about 60% of its sales—but also in non-discretionary categories like clothing and household goods.

Here are some key highlights from Walmart’s earnings:

• Consumer appeal across income levels: Walmart is attracting higher-income households (those earning over $100,000 annually). This trend signals growing price sensitivity among consumers, regardless of income.
• Grocery dominance: As grocery prices remain elevated, Walmart benefits from its strong presence in this category, making it a go-to destination for cost-conscious shoppers.
• Stock performance: Walmart’s stock chart reflects its success, showing steady growth as it outperforms its peers.

These results suggest that even as inflation cools from its peaks, consumers continue to prioritize value for their dollar. Walmart’s ability to cater to these needs positions it as a winner in today’s challenging retail environment.

On the other hand, Target’s earnings reveal a company grappling with weaker demand and operational challenges. Unlike Walmart, Target relies heavily on discretionary spending, which has been hit hard by economic headwinds and shifting consumer priorities.

Here are some key takeaways from Target’s results:

• Earnings miss: Target’s Q3 earnings per share came in at $1.85, significantly below Wall Street’s expectation of $2.30.
• Disappointing guidance: The company also lowered its Q4 earnings forecast to $1.85–2.45, well below analysts’ estimates of $2.65.
• Weak growth: Despite price cuts on over 10,000 items, Target is struggling to drive sales growth.
• Stock decline: Target’s stock has been on a downward trajectory since 2022, reflecting investor skepticism about its ability to regain momentum.

Target’s struggles emphasize the challenges facing retailers that depend on discretionary spending. With higher prices eating into disposable income, many consumers are focused on buying the essentials—a shift that plays directly into Walmart’s strengths.

A revealing picture of consumer health

The contrasting performances of Walmart and Target underscore several key trends about the economy and consumer behavior:

1. Inflation remains a concern: While inflation rates have moderated, prices are still rising year-over-year, squeezing household budgets.
2. Price sensitivity across income levels: Even higher-income households are seeking value, reflecting cautious sentiment about the economy’s trajectory.
3. A focus on essentials: Target’s struggles and Walmart’s gains highlight a consumer landscape where essential goods outperform discretionary categories.

For investors, the divergent performances of Walmart and Target highlight the importance of considering opportunity costs. While Target may eventually recover as economic conditions shift, caution is advised against “bottom fishing” for shares. Instead, Walmart’s robust position and ability to capitalize on current consumer trends make it a more attractive investment option in the retail sector.

The bottom line

Walmart’s ability to adapt to shifting consumer priorities and economic conditions underscores its position as a retail leader. Target’s difficulties, meanwhile, highlight the risks of relying too heavily on discretionary spending in a turbulent environment. As investors weigh their options, Walmart’s resilience and Target’s struggles offer valuable insights into consumer behavior, the state of the economy, and strategic investment decisions moving forward.

For more insights into the latest market-moving trends—and how to position your portfolio—join Frank and Daniel every week on WSU Premium.